(Motorsport-Total.com) – How exactly are decisions made in Formula 1? Why does it sometimes take a while for a penalty to be announced, while in other cases it happens lightning fast? The FIA has given rare insights into their processes in a recently released YouTube video, showing how complex the work behind the scenes really is.
Read more Lewis Hamilton reveals: Work on the second part of «F1» has been ongoing since 2025
At the center is the so-called Race Control. “Race control is the hub for all data and the central point for decisions,” explains FIA Sporting Director Tim Malyon. Together with numerous specialists, it ensures that races run safely, fairly, and transparently.
Collaboration behind the decisions
But race control is not solely responsible. A crucial component is the Remote Operations Centre (ROC), a kind of outsourced extension of race control. There, several experts analyze large amounts of data in parallel, review scenes, and pass their assessments on to race control.
In total, up to thirty people work directly in race control, while at the ROC, depending on the track, four to eight additional specialists are deployed. Added to this are the race stewards, who ultimately decide on penalties. They are supported by their own data analysts to efficiently evaluate the multitude of information.
From incident to possible penalty
The decision-making process usually begins with the identification of a possible incident, either through automated systems or human observers. This often initially happens in the Remote Operations Centre.
There, all relevant data is collected, including video footage, telemetry, position data, and radio messages. This information is consolidated and forwarded to race control, where a first analysis takes place.
“An incident is viewed from various perspectives,” explains Malyon. “Then we decide whether a possible rule violation exists.” Only if this is the case does the complete data package go to the stewards, who then decide on a possible penalty.
Data flood as a challenge
The amount of information is enormous. Up to 150 video channels, all team radio messages, as well as precise position and timing data of all vehicles run together in parallel. A large part of the work consists of linking this data meaningfully and interpreting it correctly. This is exactly where modern technology comes into play.
Chris Bentley, Head of Information System Strategy at the FIA, demonstrates this vividly directly on the screen. He explains how systems automatically detect whether a scene needs to be reviewed. The system continuously monitors individual track sections and filters out anomalies. “It acts somewhat as a pre-filter,” says Bentley. Even without automated analysis, incidents can thus be checked specifically and quickly.
Read more Stefano Domenicali: «The regulations definitely need to be improved!»
Track limits as a perennial issue
A particularly sensitive topic is track limits; at speeds over 200 km/h, monitoring is anything but easy. “Drivers are constantly at the limit and sometimes beyond to find performance,” says Malyon. The FIA’s task is to enforce these limits consistently and fairly.
They rely on a dual strategy. On the one hand, tracks are structurally adapted, for example through gravel traps or modified curbs, to make leaving the track less attractive. On the other hand, technical systems are increasingly used.
In the long term, the FIA pursues the so-called philosophy: “All cars, every turn.” Every car should be monitored seamlessly in every corner. For this, additional cameras, more precise positioning systems, and improved software solutions are being developed. The goal is clear. Decisions should be made within seconds, ideally before the driver reaches the next corner.
Artificial intelligence as support
Already today, the FIA uses modern technologies like computer vision to automatically detect and filter potential rule violations. About 90 percent of cases can be pre-sorted this way, allowing experts to focus on the crucial scenes.
Radio messages are now also converted into text using AI to analyze and search them faster. “At the moment, the technology mainly serves to support humans,” emphasizes Malyon. “In the future, certain processes could also be automated.”
Safety and transparency as goals
Furthermore, the FIA sees great potential in the area of safety. It is conceivable, for example, that vehicles in the future automatically react to dangers, such as by autonomously braking in the event of imminent accidents.
Closely linked to this is the demand for more transparency: In the end, the FIA is not only concerned with correct decisions but also that drivers, teams, and fans can understand how and why a decision was made. “Our goal is a clear, understandable, and transparent rule system,” says Malyon. Only in this way can trust be strengthened in the long term and ultimately the entertainment value of Formula 1 increased.
Read more Best time by Kimi Antonelli at Formula 1 test at the Nürburgring